CloudCat

I have successfully ripped many CDs without a problem, until I came to this one which is quite old. When I try to rip it, it says "Unable to create the new file. Please check your encoder settings." I've tried every possible combination but I always get this message. It is only with this CD. The CD is quite old (1990) but I've ripped older ones with no problems. What can I do? It is some of my favourite music.